What happens if you have two homeowners insurance policies?
Christopher Harper
Published Jan 20, 2026
It is not illegal to buy more than one insurance policy for your home, but doing so is unlikely to increase the amount you collect in a settlement. Because homeowner’s insurance is a standard package policy, the second policy is unlikely to offer benefits beyond those covered by the first policy.
Can you insure a house twice?
If you’re buying a new property, you can have two home insurance policies running at the same time – one for the old property and another for the new. Your premium will be recalculated for the new property. If you’ve decided to switch to a new insurance provider for your new home, you’ll need to cancel your old policy.
What happens if you have two home insurance policies?
If you report the same claim to two insurers, they will discover the multiple claims and coordinate their efforts to determine which company pays primary benefits and which pays secondary. Because homeowner’s insurance is a standard package policy, the second policy is unlikely to offer benefits beyond those covered by the first policy.
Can you file a claim with two different insurance companies?
If you have two companies because you are about to drop coverage, and the two policies will only overlap briefly, file the claim with your old insurance company. The reason for this is because you have already paid money into the policy for the old company, and this will be your only opportunity to recoup some of your investments.
Can a person buy more than one insurance policy?
When two or more insurance policies exist on the same person or property, the principle of indemnification still applies. Because you cannot profit from an insurance claim regardless of how many policies exist, most people do not buy more than one policy per item being insured.
Can you get a refund on two insurance policies?
There should be a case for a refund, usually if two different companies had the house insured each would stump up half the refund but in this case if it’s the same company then they will just cancel one and hopefully refund the cost of that one.